2020 / 04

Next Paper
DOI: 10.24075/MTCPE.2020.022

ORIGINAL RESEARCH

Clinical decision support systems in advanced qualification: history and modern trends

Kobrinskii BA1,2
About authors

1 The Federal Research Center “Computer Science and Control” of Russian Academy of Sciences, The Problem Artificial Intelligence Institute

2 Federal State Autonomous Educational Institution of Higher Education Russian National Research Medical University named after N. I. Pirogov of the Ministry of Health of Russia

Correspondence should be addressed: Kobrinskii Boris Arkadievich
ur.liam@50_abk

Received: 2020-10-20 Accepted: 2020-12-14 Published online: 2020-12-30
|
  1. Amosov N.M., Zaitsev N.G., Melnikov V.G., Popov V.A., Starchik V.N., Shulga V.A., Yanenko V.M. (1975). Medical information system. Kiev: Naukova Dumka. 508 p. (In Rus).
  2. Asanov A.A., Larichev OI, Naryzhny E.V., Strakhov S.I. (2000). ‘Expert system for the diagnosis of drug poisoning’. Seventh National Conference on Artificial Intelligence with International Participation (CAI'2000): Proceedings of the conference. Vol.2. Moscow. Publishing house of physical and mathematical literature. pp.708-716. (In Rus).
  3. Burakovsky V.I., Lishchuk V.A., Gazizova D.Sh. (1991). Aibolit is a new technology for classification, diagnosis and intensive individual treatment.Moscow. Institute of Cardiovascular Surgery. 62 p. (In Rus).
  4. Bykhovsky M.L. (1968). Solving diagnostic problems using electronic computers. Bulletin of the USSR Academy of Medical Sciences. No. 5. pp.41-52. (In Rus).
  5. Bykhovsky M. L., Vishnevsky A. A. (1971). Cybernetic systems in medicine. – Moscow: Nauka. 234 p. (In Rus).
  6. Vel’tishchev Yu.E., Belozerov Yu.M., Kobrinskii B.A. et al. (1994). Emergencies in children. Reference book. – Moscow: Medicine. 272 p. (In Rus).
  7. Vorontsov I.M., Gubler E.V., Tsybul’kin E.K. (1981). ‘Application of methods of computational diagnostics for choosing a tactical solution for threatening conditions in children’. Issues of protection of motherhood and childhood. No. 7. pp. 3-8. (In Rus).
  8. Gelovani V.A., Kovrigin O.V., Smolyaninov N.D. (1983). ‘Methodological issues of constructing expert intelligent systems’. System Research. Methodological problems, Yearbook. Moscow: Nauka. pp. 254-278. (In Rus).
  9. Gubler E.V. (1990). Informatics in pathology, clinical medicine and pediatrics. Leningrad: Medicine, Leningrad branch. 176 p. (In Rus).
  10. Demikova N.S., Lapina A.S., Putintsev A.N., Shmeleva N.N. (2007). ‘Information and reference system on congenital malformations in medical practice and education’. Doctor and information technologies. No. 6. pp. 33-36. (In Rus).
  11. Zarubina T.V., Gasparyan S.A. (1999). Control of the state of patients with peritonitis using new information technologies. Moscow. 265 p. (In Rus).
  12. Zakharova E.V. (2005). Predicting the outcomes of systemic lupus erythematosus and systemic vasculitis with extrarenal and renal manifestations. Abstract of the dissertation for candidate of medical sciences. Moscow: Russian Medical Academy of Postgraduate Education (In Rus).
  13. Kilikovsky V.V., Olympieva S.P., Kilikovsky Vl.V. (2001). ‘Computer medical advisory systems based on the representation of expert knowledge in the form of a semantic network’. Medical scientific and educational journal. No. 2. pp. 17-27. (In Rus).
  14. Kirikov I.A., Kolesnikov A.V., Rumovskaya S.B. (2014). ‘Functional hybrid intelligent system for decision support in the diagnosis of arterial hypertension’. Systems and means of informatics. Vol. 24. No. 1. pp.153–179. (In Rus).
  15. Kobrinskii B.A., Kazantseva L.Z., Fel’dman A.E. (1992). ‘Automated systems for differential diagnosis of hereditary diseases’. Hereditary human pathology. Vol. II. – Moscow. pp. 229-239. (In Rus).
  16. Kobrinskii B.A. (2014). ‘Argumentation systems: medical applications’. Scientific and technical information. Series 2: Information Processes and Systems. No. 4. pp. 9-11. (In Rus).
  17. Kobrinskii B.A. (2020). Artificial intelligence systems in medical practice: state and prospects’. Bulletin of Roszdravnadzor. No. 3. pp. 37–43. (In Rus).
  18. Kobrinskii B.A., Dolotova D.D., Donitova V.V., Gavrilov A.V. (2020). ‘Radiological images in the construction of a hybrid intelligent system’. Doctor and information technologies. No. 4. – P.43-50. (In Rus).
  19. Kobrinsky B.A., Blagosklonov N.A., Demikova N.S. (2020). ‘System for computer diagnostics of hereditary diseases’. Medical genetics. Vol.19. No. 8 (217). pp. 9-11. (In Rus).
  20. Lukashevich I.P., Machinskaya R.I., Fishman M.N. (2000). ‘Structural organization of medical information "EEG-EXPERT"’. Mathematical methods in engineering and technology MMET-2000: Proceedings of the 13th International Scientific Conference. Vol.4. SPb. pp. 154-157. (In Rus).
  21. Maryanchik B.V. (1996). ‘The method of virtual statistics and its application in partner systems for computer diagnostics’. Computer chronicle. No. 5. pp. 65-74. (In Rus).
  22. Meshalkin L. D., Goldberg S. I. (1992). ‘A new class of artificial intelligence systems (DrWt-systems)’. Izvestiya RAN. Technical cybernetics. No. 5. pp. 217-223. (In Rus).
  23. Pankratova E.S., Dobrynin D.A., Mikhailova I.N. (2012). ‘Intelligent computer system for the analysis of clinical data of patients with melanoma’. Thirteenth national conference on artificial intelligence with international participation: Proceedings of the conference. Vol.1. Belgorod. pp. 128-134. (In Rus).
  24. Pereverzev-Orlov V.S. (1990). Expert advisor. Experience in developing an affiliate system. Moscow: Nauka. 133 p. (In Rus).
  25. Sokolova L.V., Furems E.M. (2002). ‘Expert system for differential diagnosis of bronchial asthma in children’. Information technologies in health care. No.8-10. pp.14-15. (In Rus).
  26. Ustinov A.G., Sitarchuk E.A. (1994). ‘TAIS – automated medical and technological system for a therapeutic hospital’. Computer chronicle. No. 3-4. pp. 23-38. (In Rus).
  27. Finn V.K. (2004). ‘About intelligent data analysis’. News of artificial intelligence. No. 3. – pp. 3-18. (In Rus).
  28. Finn V.K., Shesternikova O.P. (2018). ‘Heuristics for detecting empirical patterns by means of JSM reasoning’. Scientific and technical information. Series 2. Information processes and systems. No.9. pp. 7-42. (In Rus).
  29. Finn V.K. (2020). ‘Precise epistemology and artificial intelligence’. Scientific and technical information. Series 2. Information processes and systems. No.6. pp. 1-36. (In Rus).
  30. Furems E.M., Gnedenko L.S. (1996). ‘STEPCLASS - a system for extracting expert knowledge and carrying out expertise for solving diagnostic problems’. Scientific and technical information. Series 2. Information processes and systems. No.9. pp. 16-20. (In Rus).
  31. Shesternikova O.P., Finn VK, Vinokurova L.V., Lesko KA, Varvarina G.G., Tyulyaeva E.Yu. (2019). ‘Intelligent system for diagnosing diseases of the pancreas’. Scientific and technical information. Series 2. Information processes and systems. No. 10. pp. 41-48. (In Rus).
  32. Adlassnig K.P., Scheithauer W., Grabner G. (1984). ‘CADIAG-2/PANCREAS: an artificial intelligence system based on fuzzy set theory to diagnose pancreatic diseases’. Third International Conference on System Science in Health Care (Munich, July, 1984). Berlin. pp. 396–399.
  33. Al-Jasmi F., Moldovan L., Clarke J.T. (2010). ‘Hunter disease eClinic: interactive, computer-assisted, problem-based approach to independent learning about a rare genetic disease’. BMC Medical Education. Vol.10. No.72. pp.11. available at: URL: https:// link.springer.com/article/10.1186/1472-6920-10-72 (Date of the application: 15.01.2021).
  34. Ben-Rassat M., Carlson R.W., Puri U.K. et al. (1980). ‘Pattern-based interactive diagnosis of multiple disorders: The MEDAS system’. IEEE Transact on Pattern analysis and machine Intelligence. Vol.2. No.2. pp.148-160.
  35. Catanzarite V.A., Greenburg A.G., Bremermann H.J. (1982). ‘Computer consultation in neurology: Subjective and objective evaluations of the «NEUROLOGIST» system’. Computers in Biology and Medicine. Vol.12. Iss.4. pp. 343-355.
  36. Chandana S., Mayorga V.R., Chan Ch.W. (2008). ‘Automated Knowledge Engineering’ // International Journal of Computer and Information Engineering. Vol.2. No.3. pp.751-760.
  37. Chang L.Ch., Tou J.T. (1984). ‘Medics – a medical knowledge system’. IEEE Transactions on Systems Man and Cybernetics. Vol.14. No.5. pp. 746-750.
  38. Corkill D.D. (1991). ‘Blackboard Systems’. AI Expert. Vol.6. No.9. (9). pp.40-47.
  39. Davis R., Buchanan B.G., Shortliffe E.H. (1977). ‘Production rules as representation for a knowledge-based consultation program’. Artificial Intelligence. Vol.8. No.1. pp.15-45.
  40. Eddy D.M. (1990). ‘Clinical decision making: from theory to practice’. JAMA. Vol.263. No. 2. pp. 287-290.
  41. Garg A.X., Adhikari N.K.J., McDonald H., Rosas-Arellano M. P., Beyene J., Sam J., Haynes R.B. (2005). ‘Effects of Computerized Clinical Decision Support Systems on Practitioner Performance and Patient Outcomes. A Systematic Review’. JAMA. Vol. 293. No.10. pp. 1223-1238.
  42. Kazemi A., Ellenius J., Pourasghar F., Tofighi S., Salehi A., Amanati A., Fors U.G. (2011). ‘The effect of Computerized Physician Order Entry and decision support system on medication errors in the neonatal ward: experiences from an Iranian teaching hospital’. Journal of Medical Systems. – 2011. Vol.35. Iss.1. pp. 25-37.
  43. Kreines M., Purtov V., Udalzov Y. (1992). ‘Diagnostic trainer-approach, model and software’. East-West Conference on Emerging Computer Technologies in Education, 6-9 April 1992, Moscow, Russia, Conference Proceedings. Moscow. pp. 181-183.
  44. Lesmo L., Marzuoli M., Molino G., Torasso P. (1984). ‘An expert system for the evaluation of liver functional assessment’. Journal of Medical Systems. Vol.8. No.1-2. pp. 87-101.
  45. Levin M.Sh., Sokolova L.V. (2004). ‘Hierarchical combinatorial planning of medical treatment’. Computer methods and Programs in Biomedicine. Vol.73. No.1. pp. 3-11.
  46. Levin M.Sh., Firer M.A. (2005). ‘Hierarchical morphological design of immunoassay technology’. Computers in Biology and Medicine. Vol.35. No.3. pp. 229-245.
  47. Lobach D.F. (1996). ‘Electronically distributed, computer generated, individualized feedback enhances the use of a computerized practice guideline’. Proceedings of the AMIA Annual Fall Symposium. pp. 493-497.
  48. Masarie F.E., Miller R.A., Myers J.D. (1985). ‘INTERNIST-I properties: Representing common sense and good medical practice in a computerized medical knowledge base’. Computers and Biomedical Research. Vol.18. No.5. pp. 458-479.
  49. Miller P.L. (1984). ‘Medical plan-analysis by computer’. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine. Vol.18. No.1/2. pp. 15-20.
  50. Miller P.L., Blumenfruchi S.J., Black H.R. (1984). ‘An expert system which critiques patient workup: modeling conflicting expertise’. Computers and Biomedical Research. Vol.17. No.6. pp. 554-569.
  51. Min H., Manion F.J., Goralczyk E., Wong Y.N., Ross E., Beck J.R. (2009). ‘Integration of prostate cancer clinical data using an ontology’. Journal of Biomedical Informatics. Vol.42. No.6. pp. 1035-45.
  52. Putintsev A., Voinova V. (2018). ‘Congenital Abnormalities: Web Application and Self-Learning Effectiveness Evaluation’. Journal of Medical Systems. Manuscript Number: JOMS-D-18-00761. 13 p.
  53. Singh-Mugica S., Tovar-Corona B., Silva-Ramirez M.A., Jimenez L.-I.G. (2016). ‘An intelligent system to assist the diagnosis of epilepsy disorder in children: A case of study’. 2016 IEEE Healthcare Innovation Point-of-Care Technologies Conference. HI-POCT 2016. Article number 7797717. pp. 142-145.
  54. Seelos H.-J. (1992). ‘A new paradigm of medical informatics’. Methods of Information in Medicine. Vol.31. No.2. pp. 79-81.